Home
  Overview
  Membership
  Members
  Topical Comment
  Links
  Events
  Case Studies
  Contact SMI
  FAQs
  Press Articles
  Publications
Case Study 2 - Reduced cultivation with disc harrows or direct drill, with surplus horsepower
Location Lincolnshire-Leicestershire border
Size, average field size and spread 400ha, 10ha
Soils and landscape Largely on dense, slowly permeable seasonally waterlogged clay soils (Denchworth association) developed on Lias Clay. Locally, more permeable sandy clay loam soils are seasonally affected by groundwater (Wigton Moor association).
Cropping 180ha winter wheat and 180ha winter oilseed rape with 40ha part permanent/part rotational set aside.
Workforce Managed by family labour (father and son) with a student at harvest.
Equipment and cultivation machinery Galucho 5m discs; Simba 12m Cambridge rolls; 2-legged mole plough; Subsoiler; Kuhn SD4000 4m Direct-Drill; 285hp CAT Challenger (8 years old); 185hp John Deere 8100 (5 years old); 130hp Renault 110-54 (8 years old); Berthoud S/P Sprayer, 3000 l/28m boom.
Cultivation Policy
After set aside land is moled, disced, roll/pressed then winter wheat direct-drilled. Sub-soiling only when necessary, usually on headlands where traffic has turned after wet harvest.
Wheat OSR Inter-crop is sprayed and oilseed rape direct-drilled
OSR wheat Disc Roll;
 
  Costings and Work rates        
Operation Output (ha/hr) Cost (£/ha) Time taken (min/ha)
Discing 4.0 12.5 15
Rolling 8.0 9.0 7.5
Direct-Drilling 4.0 35.0 15
Sub-soiling 1.0 30.0 60
Spraying 10.0 7.5 6
 
Discussion  
Decision to change Cost saving and to conserve soil moisture and allow early September drilling of winter wheat (100 seeds/m 2 – 50kg/ha) to give greatest yield potential (10t/ha).
How The Case rotary combine chops and evenly spreads both straw and chaff. Stubbles are left long (30-40cm) to improve combine output and reduce amount of straw to be chopped and re-distributed. Grass weeds are controlled in oilseed rape and broad-leaved weeds in cereals. Glyphosate is used pre-drilling. Compaction is avoided by travelling only when dry; all vehicles including combine and chaser bin are fitted with LGP tyres or tracks. Liquid fertiliser and sprays are applied down 28m tramlines to reduce wheelings.
Benefits Cost-saving: on heavy land, achieving a satisfactory seedbed with a plough-based system was a problem (4 passes with power harrow) and cost equalled £134/ha (£94/ha-light land) compared with £58/ha for direct drilling system.
  Problems   Slugs: due to oilseed rape grown close in rotation, the wetter weather and build up of surface trash. Slug pellets are not a solution to the problem.
  Solutions Found   Increasing the gap between rape crops by growing second wheat (now grass weeds controlled); establishing wheat after set-aside is a rotational change that will be made. Light discing or other suitable surface cultivation to incorporate crop residue and create a less slug-friendly environment. The use of gypsum is also an effective way to reduce slug numbers.
 
SMI COMMENT
Improved rate of work; CAT challenger relevant to “old” system; low ground pressure tyres clearly advantageous. Insufficient machinery work days for a whole farm plough based system in a wet year, risks have been minimised by the adoption of reduced cultivation systems.
 
Soil Group Type of Year M.W.D.s'   M.W.D.s'
Denchworth Normal Wet 56 27   12 0
Wigton Moor Normal Wet 86 57   22 0
Man days required to complete autumn cultivation
  180ha Wheat OSR 180ha OSR wheat  
Total Farm Conventional Plough System